“I might by no means want dying upon anybody, however I’ve learn some obituaries with nice satisfaction.” – Winston Churchill
OPINION — I affiliate myself with at the very least the latter a part of that quote from Winston Churchill with regard to Aldrich Ames. To my data, I met Ames on just one event. It was throughout a cocktail social gathering in 1989 or 1990 when he oversaw the CIA operations group answerable for what was then Czechoslovakia. I’ve no clear recollection of that occasion, however I used to be later instructed that fellow traitor Robert Hanssen was additionally in attendance. If that’s the case, to paraphrase Shakespeare: ‘Hell was empty and the devils have been there’.
Whereas I can recall little about assembly Ames at that social gathering, my colleagues and I lived – and nonetheless stay – with the results of his betrayal. The lack of an agent is a really private factor for these answerable for securely dealing with her or him. I noticed that influence up shut early on in my profession.
Towards the tip of my coaching as an operations officer in late 1982, I used to be summoned to the workplace of the then-chief of Soviet Division (SE). In that period, a summons to a gathering with any Division Chief – a lot much less the pinnacle of what was then essentially the most secretive operational part – might be unnerving for any junior officer. The preliminary moments of my appointment with then-C/SE, Dave Forden, have been appropriately unsettling. He started by asking me whether or not I had stolen something currently. Having by no means purloined something ever, I used to be bowled over. After I answered no, he requested if I may cross a polygraph examination. Once more shocked, I responded that I may the final time I took one. ‘Good’, Forden mentioned, ‘you might be coming to SE to switch Ed Howard in Moscow’. Howard, whom I had met throughout coaching, had been fired from CIA for a wide range of offenses. He later defected to the us, betraying his data of CIA operations and personnel to the KGB.
After finishing coaching, I reported to SE Division. Shortly thereafter, I used to be instructed I might not be going to Moscow in any case. As a substitute, I used to be knowledgeable, I might be going to Prague. Initially, I used to be a bit disenchanted to not have an opportunity to check my expertise towards our principal adversary. In hindsight, nevertheless, that change in plan was fortuitous. Whereas I couldn’t understand it on the time, my SE colleagues who went to Moscow can be there in the course of the grim mid-1980’s interval through which our brokers have been being rolled-up by the KGB. Many CIA officers concerned with these circumstances must stay for years thereafter questioning what had occurred to their brokers and whether or not something they’d accomplished had contributed to their arrests and executions. My colleagues’ ordeals would solely finish with the revelation that one in every of our personal was a spy.
However Ames was greater than a spy. He was a killer. His profession floundering and burdened by rising debt, Ames determined to unravel his cash issues by promoting the identities of a number of low-level CIA brokers to the KGB. Consequently, on April 16, 1985 he walked into the Soviet Embassy and handed on the next observe: “I’m Aldrich H. Ames and my job is department chief of Soviet (CI) on the CIA. […] I would like $50,000 and in alternate for the cash, right here is details about three brokers we’re creating within the Soviet Union proper now.” He hooked up a web page from SE Division’s telephone listing, together with his title underlined, to show he was real. Inside weeks, fearful that Soviet spy John Walker had been fingered by a CIA agent throughout the KGB, and fearful that he would possibly likewise be uncovered, Ames determined to comprise the entire CIA and FBI Soviet sources he knew of. “My rip-off,” he later mentioned, “was imagined to be a one-time hit. I used to be simply going to get the fifty thousand {dollars} and be accomplished with it, however now I began to panic.”
The Cipher Temporary brings expert-level context to nationwide and international safety tales. It’s by no means been extra vital to know what’s occurring on the planet. Improve your entry to unique content material by changing into a subscriber.
Accordingly, on June 13, 1985, Ames handed the Soviets what he known as “the Huge Dump.” That tranche of paperwork contained the identities of at the very least 11 CIA brokers. Courageous males who had risked all in deciding to serve freedom’s trigger, a lot of them can be arrested, interrogated and in the end executed.
Ames’s rationalization of this act says every little thing concerning the form of man he was. “All the folks whose names have been on my listing knew the dangers they have been taking once they started spying for the CIA and FBI,” he mentioned, earlier than including that, “They knew they have been risking jail or dying.”
He would repeatedly search to justify his actions by claiming that his espionage for the us was morally equal to what Western providers had lengthy accomplished towards their adversaries. Oleg Gordievsky, a British spy throughout the KGB and one of many few brokers betrayed by Ames who escaped, rightly rejected any such equivalency. “I knew,” he mentioned, that “the folks I recognized can be arrested and put in jail. Ames knew the folks he recognized can be arrested and shot. That is likely one of the variations between us.”
Sentenced to jail, Ames would spend virtually 32 years of his life behind bars. I prefer to suppose that punishment was worse than dying. One hopes he whiled away hours in his cell considering of what he’d accomplished and the lives he took. He expressed contrition in the course of the plea discount and sentencing course of to make sure leniency for his spouse, Rosario, saying, for instance, that, “No punishment by this court docket can steadiness or ease the profound disgrace and guilt I bear.”
However I very a lot doubt the sincerity of such statements as a result of he confirmed no indicators of getting a troubled conscience thereafter. As a substitute, in statements whereas incarcerated, Ames was at pains to provide his actions a veneer of ideological justification. “I had,” he mentioned, “come to consider that the espionage enterprise, as carried out by the CIA and some different American businesses, was and is a self-serving sham, carried out by careerist bureaucrats who’ve managed to deceive a number of generations of American coverage makers and the general public about each the need and the worth of their work.”
“There may be an actuarial certainty that there are different spies in U.S. nationwide safety businesses and there all the time might be.” That assertion by former CIA Chief of Counterintelligence Paul Redmond within the wake of the Ames and Hanssen circumstances displays a grim actuality of the intelligence career.
Nonetheless, after I joined CIA, it was accepted knowledge that the Company had by no means had, and will by no means have, a spy in its ranks. With the advantage of hindsight, it’s onerous to know how such a naïve conviction may have taken maintain given the repeated penetration of our predecessor group, the Workplace of Strategic Providers (OSS), and our British counterparts by Soviet intelligence. “There’ll,” as CIA Chief of CI James J. Angleton mentioned, “all the time be penetrations…it’s a lifestyle. It ought to by no means be regarded as an aberration. Anybody who will get flustered is within the incorrect enterprise.”
Maybe the downplaying of such a risk was a pure response to the overreach of Angleton himself together with his ‘HONETOL’ spy hunts which hindered the Company’s capability to mount operations towards the Soviets for years on the peak of the Chilly Conflict. It was actually a mirrored image of institutional conceitedness.
Regardless of the purpose, the concept that a overseas intelligence service may recruit a serving CIA officer as a spy was inconceivable to many. That mindset makes the accomplishment of Redmond and the Company crew led by Jeanne Vertefeuille, concluding that reporting from a Soviet mole – in the end decided to be CIA officer Aldrich Ames – was the reason for the losses, all of the extra outstanding.
Want a each day dose of actuality on nationwide and international safety points? Subscriber to The Cipher Temporary’s Nightcap e-newsletter, delivering knowledgeable insights on immediately’s occasions – proper to your inbox. Join free immediately.
The years-long hunt for the agent the KGB known as “KOLOKOL” (‘Bell’) ended on February 21, 1994 with the arrest of Ames by the FBI. The evaluation of the injury that Ames had inflicted on U.S. nationwide safety in alternate for some $2.5 million from Moscow was, not surprisingly, intensive. Even within the analogue period, he was capable of cross alongside voluminous documentary and oral reporting to Moscow. This included reporting on his personal debriefing of Vitaliy Yurchenko, who defected briefly to U.S. earlier than returning to the us.
However it was the evaluation of Ames’s position in compromising our brave brokers that struck house with us. Their sacrifice is commemorated by the CIA ‘Fallen Agent Memorial’ and different memorials inside Company areas. And one hopes that sometime the Russian folks, too, will come to understand that Navy/Technical researcher Adolf G. Tolkachev (GTVANQUISH); KGB Line PR officer Vladimir M. Piguzov (GTJOGGER); KGB Line PR officer Leonid G. Poleschuk (GTWEIGH); GRU officer Vladimir M. Vasilyev (GTACCORD); GRU officer Gennadiy A. Smetanin (GTMILLION); KGB Line X officer Valeriy F. Martynov (GTGENTILE); KGB Lively Measures specialist Sergey M. Motorin (GTGAUZE); KGB Illegals Assist officer Gennadiy G. Varenik (GTFITNESS); KGB Second Chief Directorate officer Sergey Vorontsov (GTCOWL); and the highest-ranking spy run by the U.S. towards the us; GRU Normal Dmitry F. Polyakov (TOPHAT, BOURBON and ROAM); sacrificed every little thing for them and for his or her nation.
“The lifetime of the useless,” Marcus Tullius Cicero wrote, “is positioned within the reminiscence of the dwelling.” Individually, I’ll keep in mind Ames as the bottom traitor he was and the boys he killed because the heroes they have been.
The Cipher Temporary is dedicated to publishing a variety of views on nationwide safety points submitted by deeply skilled nationwide safety professionals.
Opinions expressed are these of the writer and don’t signify the views or opinions of The Cipher Temporary.
Have a perspective to share primarily based in your expertise within the nationwide safety subject? Ship it to Editor@thecipherbrief.com for publication consideration.
Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Temporary, as a result of nationwide safety is everybody’s enterprise.
