But the Russian military continues to have interaction in determined efforts to regain restricted territory to the west. British intelligence estimates that for the reason that begin of 2025 Russia has suffered 332,000 casualties, the best loss price for the reason that invasion. Russia has made solely marginal positive factors, which Putin trumpets as victories as he throws extra males and tools into the Ukraine meatgrinder.
In fact, Putin can’t afford to confess failure, nevertheless it nonetheless appears as if he truly believes his technique is succeeding. Why?
The reply lies within the perverse incentives of Russian command and management (C2), which conceal the weaknesses of Russian FS. Russian C2 is concentrated in a single civilian with no army coaching (Putin), and his small circle of advisers.
Putin’s management discourages innovation by area officers and welcomes blind obedience. Unhealthy information from area officers of all ranks is punished with demotion or arrest. Excellent news is rewarded with promotion. Consequently, area officers routinely lie about their failures in hopes of promotion and reassignment. There may be nearly no energetic seek for info by headquarters to appropriate misinformation despatched by area officers.
Russian power buildings are notoriously corrupt—a corruption that’s anticipated and tolerated, but additionally will be an excuse for punishment. Officers steal from their models by exaggerating the dimensions of the unit and pocketing the unused pay. Therefore, many Russian models are severely understaffed. Troopers steal from their models by promoting weapons, ammunition, and gasoline, leaving their models under-equipped. The overwhelming majority of battle-hardened troopers are lengthy gone, as are army trainers, who had been all despatched to the entrance strains. New Russian recruits are untrained and unaware of the dangers they face.
Russia’s C2 and FS Issues from the Begin of the Invasion
A short evaluation makes it clear that C2 and FS issues have bedeviled the Russian invasion from the beginning of the 2022 invasion. Planning for the invasion ignored commonplace army doctrine, which emphasizes that profitable invasions require enough scale, velocity, and power. The appreciable literature on the power differentials wanted for an invasion, together with Soviet doctrine, agrees on the basic rule {that a} frontal assault requires a 3:1 power ratio to compensate for the upper casualties suffered by the invaders.
Efficient command and management are additionally important for the success of an invasion. This contains correct intelligence about enemy forces, freedom for area officers to improvise as wanted, speedy area intelligence upward to tell ways and technique because the invasion proceeds, and fast top-down selections in response to area intelligence.
The 2022 invasion violated all these necessities. With a purpose to conceal its intentions and obtain an operational shock, the planning of the invasion was restricted to a really small group led by Putin. Not even Russia’s Overseas Minister, Sergey Lavrov, was included on this group. The Russian area commanders on the bottom in Belarus for army workouts had no concept that they might be main an invasion. The success of this secrecy got here at a excessive value: there was no alternative for critiquing the invasion plan and no consideration of fall-back methods.
Russian intelligence concerning the Ukraine’s response was primarily based totally on defective assumptions {that a} high-speed invasion would demoralize the Ukrainian army, the Russian army would simply defeat the Ukrainian army on the battlefield, the highest Ukrainian leaders can be shortly captured and executed, and that the overwhelming majority of Ukrainians would both welcome the Russian invaders or stay passive.
The three:1 power differential rule ought to have required an invasion of 590,000 Russian, provided that the Russians knew the Ukrainian army had 196,600 active-duty personnel. As an alternative, the Russians deliberate an invasion of 190,000 personnel, truly smaller than the mixed Ukrainian armed forces. Even worse, as a substitute of massing its invasion power at one level to attain a breakthrough, the Russians determined to assault on six completely different axes: from the Black Sea within the southeast, from Crimea within the south, from Donbas within the east, from Belgorod within the northeast (in direction of Kharkiv), from Kursk within the northeast (in direction of Kyiv), and from Gomel, Belarus, within the north (in direction of Kyiv).
All of the Russian invasion routes confronted sudden issues, however the flaws in Russian C2 and FS will be illustrated by the destiny of Russia’s most promising assault, coming from Gomel, Belarus, and geared toward Kyiv. This included an airborne assault on Antonov airport, within the Kyiv suburb of Hostumel. The Ukrainians had not anticipated an assault from Belarus and had been unprepared for each the land invasion and the airborne assault.
Why did these assaults fail? Russian secrecy concerning the invasion had left the Russian floor forces in Belarus fully unprepared. They had been knowledgeable of their roles within the invasion solely 24 hours earlier than the invasion. Consequently, they lacked ammunition, gasoline, meals, and communications. They didn’t anticipate heavy preventing. Mud pressured their armor to make use of the few roads, inflicting site visitors jams. They encountered complete cities that weren’t on their maps, requiring them to cease and ask civilians the place they had been. Residents reported the Russian positions to Ukrainian authorities.
The Ukrainians acted swiftly to confront the Russian assault from Gomel, which was approaching the outskirts of Kyiv. They dedicated most of their obtainable particular forces and particular models of different safety models, known as up all their reserve models, and mobilized the cadets and employees of their army academies into new battalions, supported by two brigades of artillery and one mechanized brigade. Even so, the Russians had a 12:1 troop benefit on the Gomel axis. On 27 February, their advance models had been in a position to seize the suburb of Bucha, simply west of Kyiv.
Nonetheless, the cellphone calls from residents from cities within the Russian path permitted Ukrainian artillery to focus on the Russian columns. The Ukrainian forces knew the territory effectively, giving them an enormous tactical benefit, they usually had been in a position to assault the slow-moving Russian columns nearly at will, inflicting panic, abandonment of kit, and blockage of the roads. Because the Russian columns stopped shifting, their losses multiplied. The Russian advance models that had reached Bucha had been quick on gasoline, ammunition, and manpower. They assumed defensive positions, ready for reinforcements that by no means arrived.
Within the battle for Antonov airport on the sting of Kyiv, the Russians used helicopters and elite airborne troops. These troops had been to seize and execute the Ukrainian management. However the Ukrainians surrounded the airport with heavy armor, pounding the Russians. They had been in a position to seize the airport, driving the Russians into the encircling woods. Whereas the Russians had been in a position to recapture the airport after a few days, the Ukrainians had time to destroy the runways, making not possible the touchdown of reinforcements and stopping the Russians from capturing the Ukrainian management.
On March sixteenth the Ukrainian authorities introduced a counteroffensive within the Kyiv area, and by the tip of March, Russian floor forces had been retreating north from the Bucha space. By April 2nd your complete Kyiv oblast was again in Ukrainian arms, together with the realm bordering Belarus.
What was the Russian response to this humiliating defeat? These Russian generals who weren’t killed, had been largely cashiered or arrested, as had been lots of the colonels. The catastrophe resulted largely from Putin’s management, however the defeated models took the blame. This added to the inducement for officers to lie about failure and fake achievement.
The Cipher Temporary brings expert-level context to nationwide and world safety tales. It’s by no means been extra vital to know what’s taking place on the earth. Improve your entry to unique content material by changing into a subscriber.
The First Stalemate
The battle has continued by varied phases. The second part, from early April by the tip of August, 2022, was marked by energetic preventing alongside entrance strains, with heavy Russian losses, however was a relative stalemate when it comes to territorial positive factors by both aspect.
The Second Ukrainian Offensive
The third part started on September 6, 2022, when Ukrainian troops attacked the Kharkiv entrance close to the Russian border. On September 9, Ukrainian mechanized models broke by. Ukrainian forces raced north and east. The cities of Kupiansk and Izium fell to the Ukrainians on 10 September. By the subsequent day the Russian forces north of Kharkiv had retreated over the border, leaving all the Kharkiv Oblast below Ukrainian management. Urgent on to the east, Ukrainian forces on 12 September crossed the Siverskyi Donets, and on 1 October the Ukrainians recaptured Lyman, a significant railway hub, and took as prisoners an estimated 5,000 Russian troops.
As Russian forces rushed to the northeast entrance, Ukraine launched its counteroffensive within the Kherson area on October 2. By 9 October Ukrainian forces had retaken 1,170 sq. kilometers of territory, urgent on towards the Dnieper River and town of Kherson. On 11 November, Kherson was occupied by the Ukrainians.
The Second Stalemate
The second interval of stalemate dates from 12 November 2022 till the current. Throughout this three-year interval, the battle has seen the introduction of drone warfare on a large scale, first by Ukraine after which by Russia. Because of the drone warfare, your complete battle has modified in character. Drones have made assaults by armored automobiles so pricey that the battle has reverted to trench warfare paying homage to World Battle I. Drones now account for two-thirds or extra of front-line casualties within the battle.
Ukraine’s authorities discarded Soviet-era laws to supply tax breaks and revenue incentives to impartial Ukrainian drone producers, authorizing the Ukrainian army to contract with them. These impartial corporations have made good use of Ukraine’s massive cadre of expert aeronautical engineers and knowledge know-how specialists. About 200 of those corporations are formally acknowledged to obtain army contracts, and as many as 300 different teams manufacture drones and donate them on to army models. Nonetheless, monetary sources stay a limiting issue.
Want a day by day dose of actuality on nationwide and world safety points? Subscriber to The Cipher Temporary’s Nightcap publication, delivering professional insights on right now’s occasions – proper to your inbox. Join free right now.
Russia has quickly developed its personal drone capability. Furthermore, Russia has the sources to outproduce Ukraine, even when its drones are much less subtle. Russian drone manufacturing is restricted much less by funds than by the seek for microchips, smuggled from the west or purchased from China. Russia additionally has ballistic and airborne missile programs which can be arduous for Ukraine to carry down. Russia has been utilizing huge barrages of drones and missiles to demoralize Ukraine. However this effort is counterproductive. Bombings anger enemy populations and stiffen resistance, as proven in WWII by the Blitz of London and Allied carpet bombings of Germany. Russian barrages might have strained Ukraine’s economic system, however they haven’t lessened resistance.
Whereas the drone/missile battle is well-known, Ukraine’s different protection trade progress is much less recognized. Ukraine now produces extra artillery shells than all of NATO’s 32 members and Europe. Since 2022, home manufacturing of armored personnel carriers has elevated by 400 %, artillery by 200 %, ammunition by 150 %, and anti-tank weapons by one hundred pc. By 2025, a single Ukrainian manufacturing unit was producing 20 Bohdana howitzers every month, related in specs to the French Caesar. Ukrainian protection corporations ship howitzers in 60 days for $2.5 million in comparison with a several-year wait and a price of $4.3 million within the West.
Russia has needed to develop a brand new tactical method for the energetic fronts. Teams of two or three troopers are pressured (by firing squads) to run in direction of Ukrainian strains and in the event that they dwell, conceal themselves to struggle later. Specialised models reminiscent of snipers, artillery spotters, or drone operators attempt to determine and goal the sources of firing at these people. Then bigger assault models transfer ahead to seize territory. Nonetheless, these assault models are actually poorly skilled, and their tools is out of date armor or extra typically merely vehicles, vans, and bikes, typically closely camouflaged. Ukrainian spotter drones are ready for these assaults, and as soon as the Russian automobiles are in movement and supported by Russian artillery, Ukrainian drones blow up each the automobiles and the artillery. On a typical day in autumn 2025, the Russians had been dropping 1,000 troopers, 10 armored models, 25 artillery barrels, and 100 automobiles. By providing more and more excessive incentives, Russia was recruiting 30,000 troopers a month, barely sufficient to cowl losses.
Russian digital warfare has improved dramatically, with a give attention to disrupting Ukrainian drones. Consequently, Ukrainian forces are actually dropping about 10,000 drones per 30 days. Russian air defenses even have improved, decreasing the flexibility of Ukrainian fighter jets to assault. Russian engineers have been efficient in designing and constructing defensive trenchworks, minefields, and tank traps in areas they management.
Nonetheless, Ukraine air defenses have additionally improved. Russian airplanes now should launch airborne missiles from Russian territory, with a substantial lack of accuracy. Russian floor to floor ballistic missiles are arduous to carry down, but additionally lack accuracy.
Confronted with the hardening of Russian entrance strains, Ukrainian forces are centered on inflicting excessive Russian casualties, somewhat than attacking themselves. The exception happens when the Ukrainians determine to roll again a Russian salient to forestall it from being hardened. The huge Russian missile and drone assaults deep in Ukraine have required the Ukrainians to speculate closely in missile and drone defenses of all kinds, which have one thing like a 90% success price. Nonetheless, Ukraine suffers appreciable injury. This serves as a continuing reminder to Ukrainians of what’s at stake.
Conclusion
Putin’s battle in Ukraine has supplied him with a rationale for stifling dissent in Russia, redirecting huge sources to show Russia’s economic system to army manufacturing, sponsoring efforts to overturn governments that assist Ukraine, and making ready for extra invasions that can re-establish the Russian empire and cement his legacy as a contemporary Stalin.
Despite all this, Putin continues to be dropping the battle in Ukraine. That battle is chewing up males and tools at an unsustainable price. Furthermore, it has been a strategic catastrophe. The battle strengthened Ukrainian nationalism. It energized the European members of NATO and induced Finland and Sweden to affix NATO, which doubled the size of NATO’s frontier with Russia. It destroyed the parable of Russian army superiority. It ended Russian pure fuel exports to the European Union, which had been rigorously cultivated for many years. It led to the emigration of greater than half one million of Russia’s greatest and brightest.
Most NATO international locations are actually rearming and increasing their militaries. The E.U. international locations mixed gross home revenue EU GDP of $19.4 trillion in 2024 added to the UK GDP of $3.6 trillion totaled over 23 trillion {dollars}, whereas the gross home revenue of the Russian Federation RF GDP in 2024 was 2.1 trillion. Over the long term, Russia can’t compete with Western Europe. Europe can afford to assist Ukraine’s economic system and battle effort whereas European international locations ramp up their protection industries and army infrastructure. Putin will ultimately lose not solely his Ukraine Battle, but additionally his dream of a brand new Russian empire.
The Cipher Temporary is dedicated to publishing a spread of views on nationwide safety points submitted by deeply skilled nationwide safety professionals.
Opinions expressed are these of the creator and don’t characterize the views or opinions of The Cipher Temporary.
Have a perspective to share primarily based in your expertise within the nationwide safety area? Ship it to Editor@thecipherbrief.com for publication consideration.
Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Temporary as a result of Nationwide Safety is everybody’s enterprise.
