What, precisely, does a Director of Cognitive Benefit do? It’s not a title most Individuals encounter, and it sits far exterior the acquainted contours of diplomacy, army power, or financial leverage. However as Chenoweth explains, the competition for affect now not stays neatly inside these lanes both.
His focus is usually on the grey area – the place info, notion, tradition, and conduct collide, and the place adversaries like China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea are working with staggering assets and strategic focus.
On this Cipher Temporary dialog, Chenoweth breaks down how cognitive operations truly work, why the U.S. has struggled to maintain tempo, and what it means to offer the President an “info possibility” that’s not merely kinetic or financial.
He provides uncommon, candid perception into how know-how, AI, and social platforms—from TikTok to algorithmically pushed personas—are reshaping the battlespace sooner than policymakers can write doctrine.
Our dialog is a deep dive into one of many least understood – however maybe most consequential – fronts of contemporary nationwide safety. Our dialog has been evenly edited for size and readability.
Shawn Chenoweth
Shawn Chenoweth is the Director of Cognitive Benefit on the US Nationwide Safety Council.
The Cipher Temporary: How do you clarify the position of the director of Cognitive Benefit?
Chenoweth: If you take a look at conventional parts of army energy, you in all probability consider the DIME assemble. It is not an ideal assemble, but it surely’s fairly good. DIME, is damaged down into Diplomatic, Data, Navy and Financial, and it’s extremely clear who owns the Diplomatic, Navy, and Financial elements. However there hasn’t been, not less than in a number of many years, instance of the place individuals have actually come to the president and the administration with an “I” possibility, for Data. And it is a disgrace as a result of whenever you truly take a look at the DIME assemble, you do not wish to break it into range pipes. We should always consider it as a cell. Every of these parts acts as a part of a functioning cell, and eradicating any of these parts means you will have an imperfect or failing cell.
So, I used to be requested to assist put the “I” again in DIME in order that we are able to present extra choices and benefits throughout the opposite parts of DIME to nationwide energy and supply the president with alternatives to perform the Administration’s aims that are not simply warheads on foreheads or threatening economics or expending political leverage. We are able to improve these issues, however we are able to additionally achieve benefits by utilizing cognitive results via the knowledge setting.
Kelly: Let’s set the stage a bit additional. When you had been to clarify to the typical American what is going on when it comes to cognitive warfare within the grey zone – the realm the place battle happens beneath the extent of warfare – how would you describe it?
Chenoweth: I believe in the event you look via your army histories, philosophers, politicians, political science, it is all fairly clear. You’ll be able to select the weather. All of them have one underlying thread, which is that political victory is the one which issues at its core. That is actually what we’re speaking about. Nothing’s modified. How human beings are linked, how know-how is affected has actually modified. However what we actually care about is what individuals do in the actual world and the geophysical world, the world we dwell in.
So, the purpose of a cognitive benefit is to leverage that in order that human beings are taking behaviors favorable to outcomes, to nationwide aims, which more often than not are additionally – within the case of the USA – favorable in their very own proper. So it is core. And that’s what we’re driving to get: these benefits in what individuals do in the actual world via their sensing, to make choices that come again to the actual world and have the consequences that you really want.
Kelly: Are you able to give an instance of what that might appear to be?
Chenoweth: As an example you are negotiating for a bit of land or a base that you simply want for overflight intel assortment. You are going to conduct a trade-off in negotiations. Perhaps it will appear to be, – in the event you pay extra, you may get extra – primarily based off what the worth proposition is. However very not often is it that blatant and easy. So, what you need to have the ability to do is perceive, what benefit would we want within the negotiation? What’s truly driving this different social gathering apart from perhaps simply value or simply hazard? What’s the chance calculus?
There are cultural nuances that have an effect on issues: their understanding of affect, political implications. So, the purpose can be to know why they’d have an interest on this within the first place? What benefit does it give them? What are the cultural nuances? Why would not they do that within the first place? Why aren’t they taking this motion and what can we do to make it possible for the end result is what we would like?
There are different areas the place that applies throughout the spectrum.
As an example we’re conducting counter-terrorism operations, and we all know an goal tends to make use of a selected cafe. Effectively, what in the event that they had been utilizing a distinct one which day? What can we do to affect them to go to a spot that is extra favorable for choices to lower our personal danger calculus, both as a result of we wish to conduct a kinetic strike or make an arrest? Perhaps we will not discover them. So, what if we use that for our intel assortment and our strategies to mainly make them come up on comms and alter their conduct so it is simpler to search out them, accumulate on them, and construct the info in order that we are able to conduct bodily actions to cease or disrupt them? And you may form of see how that applies throughout the board.
If you recognize greater than the individual you are coping with, likelihood is that you will be higher at engaging in your consequence. It’s very comparable with the werewolf concept. It is a sport the place two persons are chosen to be the werewolf of the village and everybody else within the group would not know who the werewolf is. More often than not the people who find themselves the werewolves win the sport as a result of they’ve an info benefit over everybody else taking part in the sport. So, it is a human norm.
And once more, I level out that nothing’s new below the solar. It is simply that we have not actually thought via the implications of what it means within the info age that we dwell in – the place everyone seems to be linked via software program outlined radios. We’re a great distance away from direct sensing the place it is communication and issues taking place in the actual world. Now we now have form of oblique sensing the place you are fed information feeds and all the things else. We are able to have an effect on cognitive conduct in methods we by no means imagined, and we actually have not thought via simply as we are able to attain individuals and promote objects. And if I wish to discover an individual whose favourite colour is purple, who’s a army age male who’s actually into Magnum PI, I can discover that individual because of their radio, and I can craft messages particularly for somebody who suits that demographic and transfer them in a selected route. That is the primary time in historical past that that is been the case.
Kelly: You’ve gotten a background that mixes each authorities and personal sector expertise. Provided that know-how is being quickly developed within the non-public sector, how do you assume that background offers you a bonus on this position?
Chenoweth: There are lots of people who’ve served within the army and have been contractors however simply by happenstance, I occur to have been in a number of vital areas at vital instances. I believe one of many benefits that has introduced me is that I noticed the frustration throughout the army when the contracting equipment did not work. I used to be additionally empowered by trade to go and repair a number of these constructions and allow the federal government to do it, and now I am getting afforded the chance to work on coverage to make the system actually hum.
I believe the benefit with that’s that with regards to the knowledge area, there is not any management. And I attempt to emphasize this to any coverage maker or energy dealer or resolution maker that I can discover. You’ll be able to put an armored brigade in an intersection – absolutely outfitted, absolutely supported – and a U.S. Armored Brigade might personal that intersection. There are issues you possibly can management. However with regards to the knowledge area, there isn’t any management. It’s consistently shifting, consistently altering. You’ve gotten a binary resolution. You’re both going to take part, ideally at a stage that issues, or not, and no matter’s going to occur goes to occur.
So, you might end up in an advantageous info area within the morning, lose it by the late morning, get a stalemate within the afternoon, and win it again within the afternoon – simply to lose it once more on the finish of the day. And whenever you get up the subsequent morning, you are going to should do it another time. There isn’t any, “We’ve got info dominance and we’re achieved and we are able to crack our beers and go on with different issues.”
That is not how this works as a result of every single day new info is being injected into the system. Persons are altering and growing new opinions. Issues are occurring and persons are going to react to these issues, change their opinions, adapt, age out, age in, so these cultural references might change. It is a fixed flux. One of many issues that from the U.S. authorities aspect we’re getting our head round is that we want an info provider group consistently working afloat within the info setting, successfully. One which’s engaged 24/7 to have an effect on these modifications.
The Cipher Temporary is partnering with the Data Professionals Affiliation and the Nationwide Middle for Narrative Intelligence to deliver you Pinnacle 2026: Grey Zone Convergence: Cognitive Safety on the Intersection of Affect, Innovation, and Shared Pursuits. Register for the February 9-10 convention now to safe your spot.
Kelly: It is not simply the USA that has gotten fairly good at understanding the influence of cognitive benefit. We see these techniques from China and Russia getting used with gorgeous success. On this position, how centered are you on their actions with regards to doing the very same factor that you simply’re tasked with doing?
Chenoweth: They completely follow these actions. I name them the ‘CRINKETT’. Each problem we’re typically coping with falls within the CRINKETTS. It is China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, Terrorists and Trans[national] criminals. And notably for the nation states, that is precisely how they wish to compete.
From their perspective, there are two methods to cope with the USA: asymmetrically and stupidly, largely due to our financial and army energy. They get that. They don’t seem to be taken with a kinetic struggle; that’s an terrible prospect. So the best way they wish to do that is in grey zone actions, within the info area, within the cognitive area.
They usually outspend us. I am not going to say essentially outperform, however I will say if you wish to compete at a stage that issues, they outspend us, interval. Iran in all probability spends round $1.8 billion plus-minus a 12 months, perhaps extra with their proxies and all the things else they do on this specific area. Russia – submit Ukraine invasion, spends about $2.6 billion, one thing like that. China – 48 plus billion {dollars} a 12 months. The U.S., if I take all the actions from the DoD, the State Division and all the things else, and you place these collectively, you would possibly strategy $1.2 billion.
It doesn’t suggest we’re executing these funds both. It simply implies that that is what we have allotted. When you concentrate on how we outspend to have a bonus on the opposite components of DIME, we’re hideously underperforming right here. And once more, all props to the administration. They’re conscious about this and the help I’ve had on the Nationwide Safety Council and throughout the weather of presidency – the departments and companies – has been stellar. And we’ll proceed to work on this and get it proper as a result of we now have three and a half extra years of President Trump’s administration to get this proper, do the reps and units, and make this a sturdy coverage in order that the American individuals can begin having fun with these advantages that come after we’re actually centered on this area.
Kelly: What does success appear to be for you on this position and the way do you measure it?
Chenoweth: Measurement has at all times been a humorous factor. Individuals will consistently inform me how arduous it’s to measure these actions. And what I’ve discovered time and time once more is that we’re truly fairly good at these actions. The problems with the measurements are, once more, taking part at a scale that issues. We have to measure conduct change, and to be able to do this, we have to have clear aims. What are we after?
The massive a part of that’s who’s the target market that has the company to do the factor we would like? We spend a number of time planning and CONOPS [Concept of Operations] on sub-target audiences that do not even have the company – in hopes that they have an effect on company – and that is completely fantastic. However why are we doing assessments in opposition to this? We spend a number of money and time producing assessments to focus on audiences that do not have the company you need. So, let’s give attention to the target market that has the company and let’s do that at scale.
For instance; I am within the DC space and I can go all the way down to the Potomac River, drop a bucket of water within the river, and I’ve objectively molecularly elevated the quantity of water within the Potomac. There is not a sensor on this planet that’s going to detect that molecular change.
The actual fact is that you simply could be having an impact, however you do not have a sensor that’s going to choose that up. So, that you must enhance your scale or customise your sensing system to the impact you are having. That tends to be the place the assessments disintegrate.
I’ve heard on a regular basis for many years now that assessments are so arduous. I do not discover that to be true. What I discover is that you have sacrificed assessments for impact, which is ok. It is danger calculus. If I had a low quantity of assets and I made a decision to place as a lot into the impact I’ve needed, that is fantastic. However on the finish of the day, you are in search of the actual conduct change within the focused viewers that issues. What are the sensors you will have on that and what are you doing to gather that information: public opinion, analysis surveys, constructing the networks. We will see this exacerbate additional because the AI revolution continues at tempo.
Kelly: How is know-how impacting what you are attempting to do, your mission, after which how are you additionally working with the non-public sector as a result of the non-public sector is controlling a lot of the know-how and the innovation that the federal government must work with. So how are you doing that?
Chenoweth: One of many challenges I see rising from AI is that there is form of an assumption that AI will repair all of your woes. I’ve seen the very best instruments on the market do one factor: they mannequin the info they’ve, and that is the core subject. We do not have the info. So once more, I am again to there’s not an entire lot of latest issues below the solar. And the AI fashions are actually good, and it could possibly permit you to discover new insights from the info that you’ve got, however new information must be created. So, sacrificing assortment methodologies and new approaches to collect the info on the foot of a mannequin is horrible.
The AI snake oil salesman I might cope with in trade on a regular basis would are available in and say, ‘Oh, you are taken with that? I might completely mannequin you the factor.’ Cool. How does that work? ‘Effectively, all you must do is present me the info and we’ll put all this collectively and provide the insights.’ I am like, whoa. We do not have the info both. Nobody has the info. That is form of the issue. So, let’s be sincere about what we’re doing.
AI goes to be a terrific boon for trade and for the federal government and everybody else below the solar. It may clearly have influence, however I believe as that strikes ahead, we have to begin how we truly make use of it. Constructing an agent or a token for each employee so that they are augmented by an AI that does the factor that they themselves might not be good at or saving them time goes to be superb, but it surely must be undergirded by with the ability to detect what’s truly taking place out in the actual world. And people two issues usually are not essentially – not interrelated. As I mentioned, most issues are variety of an entire cell that function in a single unit, and we will not essentially bifurcate this stuff after which count on good outcomes.
Former Senior CIA Govt Dave Pitts wrote a three-part sequence solely for The Cipher Temporary on what the U.S. can do to change into extra aggressive within the Grey Zone. Subscriber+Members can learn it right here. Want entry? We may also help with that.
Kelly: So you will have a mission that’s tough to measure, is vastly impactful, adversaries are utilizing it as effectively in opposition to Americans successfully, and in some circumstances, these adversaires are dedicating much more assets to this. When you might explaine to the typical U.S. citizen how they could be focused by cognitive operations which might be carried out by U.S. adversaries, what would you inform them to search for?
Chenoweth: It’s essential to be conscious of sources clearly. After I take a look at the assemble of how we strategy cognitive warfare, I believe one of many greatest issues I’ve had for not less than the final 10 years has been the assemble of dis- and misinformation. My subject is not the dis- and misinformation assemble. It is the overuse of it.
Disinformation and misinformation are issues. They’ve which means. However they imply one thing that’s true and folks use it for issues that aren’t true. For instance, disinformation are lies. The individual projecting the knowledge is aware of it is a lie. They’re doing it to perform an goal. The larger downside of disinformation is misinformation. These are people who find themselves sharing these lies, not understanding they’re lies, or taking issues out of context like satire, et cetera, and propagating as if it had been reality. These are what these are.
However not all the things we now have to cope with falls into that assemble. There are two different parts to this that we now have to be conscious of.
One is lacking info, which used to imply that the target market wasn’t knowledgeable sufficient to make an accurate resolution, favorable to them or anybody else. ‘It is a tragedy that your member of the family died and you must mourn their loss, however cease touching the physique. That is the way you’re spreading Ebola’, proper? Fairly simple, fairly easy.
Now that we’re coping with nation states with deep pockets, that is been flipped up on its head and so they’re training energetic lacking info, the place they may present wire companies into a rustic saying, ‘Congratulations, you need to use our wire service free of charge and we’ll present you all of the stuff, and that is your greatest value apart from labor. Is not that great? The catch is that you simply simply have to make use of our wire service’.
When you assume [contextual] tales are going to get into the press via these channels, good luck. This is not taking place within the third world. These are taking place in main international locations and locations that might shock you.
Think about one thing like, ‘When you run this story, all our linked companies which might be linked via us or different means are going to tug their promoting funds from you.’ So once more, good luck speaking in regards to the story in your setting. Nobody’s going to the touch it. No influencer needs a bit of it as a result of they are going to lose their incentive construction and their income stream. It is issues like that.
On the opposite aspect of the coin, and the larger downside, is the rhetoric info. These are the issues that are not essentially true or false. They’re framed by your worth system, the way you view issues, what you assume reality truly is.
There are individuals on the market who will say, I believe a communist socialist type of authorities that’s extremely authoritarian is extra steady and subsequently higher than a liberal democracy. There are individuals who consider that, and simply by saying, effectively, historical past would show you in any other case, it isn’t a ok argument. It’s essential to interact with these individuals at a scale that issues and be ready to win the argument.
We have seen this time once more on the counter-terrorism entrance the place we’d shut down the comms of a no one, and abruptly that individual would come again with the fame that was so priceless, and now they seem to be a terrorist thought chief as a result of the Western world thought that they had been so harmful they wanted to be shut down as an alternative of simply accepting the very fact, that perhaps we must always simply interact with this man as a result of nobody’s ever heard of him and perhaps we must always simply level out that he is a moron.
There are methods to cope with this, and simply because we do not like one thing doesn’t suggest it is a mislead the person who’s spreading it. They may consider it. Earlier than we simply title one thing disinformation and say, effectively, it is a lie and we are able to ignore it — that’s not enough within the fashionable period the place everyone seems to be linked as a result of, once more, this individual has connective tissue to the web. They’ve internet platforms. They are often simply as linked as a authorities if they need to select to be and if they’ve the recognition, as a result of at its core, no matter whether or not or not you are a authorities or a celeb or anything, you’re preventing for consideration.
Kelly: It’s typically tough for busy Individuals to navigate the knowledge area in the present day and know what to consider with out inviting some severe time into the supply. Do you take a look at a part of your mission on this position as serving to individuals perceive extra of the context they want to be able to make good choices?
Chenoweth: I have been extra on the aspect coping with overseas audiences. However even in that regard, I believe that it actually issues to ask what are the issues that we all know to be what we really feel are goal truths and issues that matter? Issues that we would like goal audiences to know as a result of we all know it will be higher for them and higher for our aims?
After which what are the issues the place we simply wish to make it possible for if a debate must be had, we facilitate the talk in order that the target market, notably with an American target market – which once more, it isn’t my forte, we do not do this in authorities or should not — that must be facilitated by Individuals mentioning to one another that we do have to have these debates and are available to form of consensus, understanding that there can be disagreements.
Kelly: Do you assume your job goes to be much more vital sooner or later or perhaps much less?
Chenoweth: I’ve by no means thought the job wasn’t vital. I believe the factor I am having fun with proper now could be that everybody’s form of getting their head round what this implies. The overused expression that ‘We have to do some issues on Fb,’ whenever you would have policymakers say, ‘Effectively, I am involved that that might destroy Amazon and web commerce’ and your head would explode as you are attempting to clarify, ‘That is simply not how the web works, man.’
We will be comfy working on these platforms and doing issues that we have to do with out destroying web commerce or the web. And now I believe a number of coverage makers and trade are all linked. They’re much more comfy doing this stuff. Now’s the time when we have to get to the place the assets and the permissions actually match the flexibility to get us the place we must be.
I’ve typically not discovered too many authority issues. I typically discover permissions issues. I discover that with regards to authorities, you virtually at all times discover that each group truly has a framework that enables them to do issues. It is simply that somebody someplace within the chain can say no and is all too comfy saying no, as a result of, notably prior to now administration, they had been very comfy at avoiding danger and never as comfy at managing danger. And that may be a dynamic that we now have to alter. The world is a dangerous place, and we must be on the market taking part in it, throwing our elbows round and managing the chance, not avoiding it.
Kelly: How arduous of a job is it to offer the U.S. the cognitive benefit in in the present day’s world?
Chenoweth: It is arduous, tremendously arduous since you’re speaking about altering tradition. I do not assume the exercise itself and the coverage and the issues that may be achieved are arduous. I believe the arduous half can be altering the tradition and altering individuals’s mindsets.
We have talked about the truth that there was once three domains: bodily area, info area and cognitive area. We’ve got to discover the knowledge area and truly name it what it’s. There may be the bodily area, the geophysical area. However I just like the ‘kill internet’ strategy. A very good kill internet will represent a kill chain that’s disrupted, and we now have to get out of only a kill chain. We have to get right into a kill internet mentality with regards to cognitive results.
Kelly: Clarify what you imply by a “kill internet”?
Chenoweth: You’ve gotten your geophysical world the place issues exist in the actual world, the place the place all of us dwell. In relation to the knowledge area, although, it used to consolidate a bunch of issues.
The fact is that after we break that down right into a kill internet, you are wanting out of your bodily area as much as your logic layer. The web just isn’t some amorphous cloud that wanders round. It is composed of a system of programs that dwell in the actual world. It is information facilities, servers, modems, et cetera. The place does that infrastructure truly exist? Typically the recordsdata are within the pc. So, we must be conscious of the place does that work? How does the web, how do these constructions work, the cell networks, et cetera.
From there, it then creates the digital layer, the place all of the trons are that exist. You’ll be able to have results, that is the place your actual our on-line world comes into play. That is how the cell gadgets work, however that’s simply information.
Then it goes as much as the persona entity stage. These are the actual human beings, typically pretend human beings, they’re personas, organizations however entities that doubtlessly might be focused or addressed or engaged, et cetera.
After which there’s the cognitive area. The trick within the cognitive area is what occurs within the thoughts. And that thoughts is influenced by the sensing that goes up via that chain after they course of it. You are in a position to interdict on its means up or affect, and also you’re in a position to affect on the best way down when a call is made.
For instance, when one thing occurs in the actual world, it is communicated to a call maker, however it will undergo the logic layer transmitted via sensors, computer systems, emails, telephones, et cetera, to individuals and entities who’re going to course of it themselves, talk it to a call maker who’s going to decide primarily based off that info, or a person or a bunch of people.
They’re all going to make choices on easy methods to react to that or not react to that. And that is going to return all the way down to the bodily world after they say, ‘I do not actually like what is going on’, or perhaps ‘I do like what’s taking place. Let’s do the factor’. They will talk that all the way down to ‘Sure, launch the missiles’, or ‘Let’s have a protest’. So, you possibly can have an effect on the chain up. You’ll be able to have an effect on the chain down, however that is the way it works.
We as the USA have a pipe that exists inside that kill internet construction – so does everybody else. And it would not matter in the event you’re a nation state or a household or a person. You’ve gotten your sensing sources.
As I discussed earlier, the direct conversations between individuals in the actual world – even now, you and I are speaking utterly over that whole construction – and that construction might be affected on the best way up as we’re speaking to when that is lastly produced and goes again out to the actual world the place abruptly I’ve AI results on me and I am saying issues I by no means meant to say, however the remainder of the world’s now deciphering that.
I did not say that, that wasn’t my cognitive resolution, however you intercepted on the best way down and now you’ll inadvertently have an effect on everybody else’s cognitive strategy to what I am speaking.
Kelly: What does the long run from a know-how and AI standpoint actually appear to be?
Chenoweth: It is having elementary modifications. It may be attention-grabbing to see what occurs within the leisure trade as AI takes over and abruptly individuals can have extra entry. We have seen how the music trade went via large change simply on streaming music. We’re about to witness what that is going to appear to be from our extra conventional platforms. We have seen how issues transfer from streaming. I believe there’s a stage of adaptation that is going to go together with that.
One of many issues that must be addressed is how precisely we’ll interact. There’s a level the place we must be comfy with giving form of steerage to the AIs – human within the loop – however in the event you assume that you are going to have the ability to assessment each single message that should exit in an AI-driven world, you are out of your thoughts.
So, you want to have the ability to be comfy producing on your target market profiles and provides form of thematic steerage and let the AI do some stage of engagements in opposition to overseas audiences to steer conversations in a selected route, or not less than determine the place a dialog could be going so you possibly can intervene when it appears to be like like choices are being made in a nasty means, after which discover out if that’s an open and sincere cultural nuance factor the place it’s about engagement or if it is being steered by your opponent.
I believe that we’re not far, and we’re in all probability already in a sport, the place there are AIs versus AIs as we converse within the info setting.
Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Temporary as a result of Nationwide Safety is Everybody’s Enterprise.
